Recently, we have seen so many photos like this one. We have heard the videos and audio samples of wailing children separated from loved ones as the families were confronted by US Border Patrol. I want to make one thing perfectly clear, as I will limit comments strictly to the children, this post is not about the fact that the acts that led to this situation were illegal entry into the United States. No one can deny that. This post however, is about the horrific treatment of the children.
Now take a look at these two photos. Just as the photo above, the children are being subjected to a forced separation. But there is one major difference.
While both of my daughters, who are adopted from China, were “abandoned,” which at some point my daughters will most likely have to reconcile that time in their lives, for a brief time in their lives, they were in the care of someone who truly meant everything to them, and in an instant, they were gone, and the children were placed in the arms of a stranger. It made no difference that I had made the commitment to love and care for each of my daughters for the rest of our lives. Even as infants, I was taking them from the only people they knew, and relied on.
In the time that followed, there would be occasional issues of stress from the memories of the trauma, something called a “night terror.” Any parent who has ever witnessed this type of episode, best described as worse than an actual nightmare, the child experiencing the night terror exhibits intense fear, shrieking screams, flailing arms and legs, just to describe some of the actions.
But make no mistake, these often are the result of some sort of trauma. And for small children, whose brains are in no way developed to deal with this intense stress, the lingering and late effects of this trauma, can have a profound impact that can and most likely will affect the child for the rest of their lives.
The other major difference however, is how the children are dealt with following that initial trauma. Is there constant nurturing following the separation? Is there an opportunity for the child to establish and build a new bond of trust before the trauma becomes overwhelming?
While I cannot speak for other adoptions, speaking for my daughters, the answers are “yes”. I was able to respond to their cries of fear and sadness. I was able to comfort them and hold them. I spent the next six months after their adoption bonding with them every moment I could, one on one. They learned through consistency that I was someone who they could trust, someone who was not going to hurt them, someone who would protect them. While our family unit structure has changed in recent years, my daughters continue to grow with a loving father, showing no signs or issues from the traumatic events that they experienced over a decade ago.
But when it comes to the more than 2000 children who have been separated from their actual family members, it is going to be a much different story. Federal workers are not allowed to comfort or console the children. Instead of a cozy home, the children are kept in cages (there is no other way to describe the enclosures). There is no one on one comforting or nurturing. If they are lucky, perhaps another child may give the hug and comfort that is desperately needed. The emotional trauma and the lack of consolation is going to impact these children for the rest of their lives.
I get why the parents of these migrant children wanted to come to the United States. Both of my daughters came from similar environments, a mother hoping for better for her children. People often comment how “lucky” my children are. No, they are not lucky. They were taken from everything they knew. They did not volunteer. But where I am lucky, is that they do not harbor any resentment for adopting them. Where I am lucky, is that I am a proud father of two beautiful and well adjusted children. Where I am lucky, we are family.
Our government has realized, and perhaps too late for some, their actions of splitting up the children from the families after crossing the border was a mistake, a huge mistake. The children were pawns in an attempt at immigration reform, and the price came at the children’s expense. And there are no doubts this will have a negative impact on most of the children, if not all. At least, the separations have stopped, but what happens next is just as upsetting, and really, disgraceful. If you study history, look up “Japanese Internment Camps” and you will see that this will most likely be the next step in dealing with the illegal immigration situation and not splitting up families. And if by some chance this does not happen, the most immediate and daunting, if not impossible task, is reuniting the children with their loved ones. It is encouraging that it is reported that of the 2300 separated children, 500 have been reunited. But for others, the odds are not good because of lack of documentation and communication.
As I mentioned, as part of the adoption process, my daughters had to officially been declared “abandoned.” And China had a process for proving such a horrific status. And once deemed official, the adoption could commence. But with “abandoning” a child being illegal in China, locating either parent is next to impossible as the parent would likely be arrested if they ever came forward. That does not mean that I have not taken steps to make it possible one day, if my daughters so choose, to try to locate their biological parents. In the movie “Somewhere Between” (which my oldest daughter makes a cameo appearance), one of the children in the movie actually locates her birth parents (sorry for the spoiler alert), so I know that it can be done, difficult, but not impossible.
But with the nightmare unfolding with these migrant children, it has been discovered that for many, even most, there is no documentation or information of what children belong to what family, how to reunite the children with their family, and worse, having no idea where the children have even been sent to. Government agencies and the companies operating the detention centers offer no transparency, clearly because they have royally f*cked up! And clearly, they have no idea how to undo what they have done. Shit! The governor of New York was not even aware, that he has over 700 of these separated children in the New York foster system, because HHS has issued a gag order on the foster system. Clearly, this is wrong and our government knows it.
Again, the argument is not about what is legal immigration and what is not. We know the difference. But having been to a country where things are not good, and as a man who has some religious faith, I have no right to judge another, especially one who wants nothing more than a better life for their children, and the risks they are willing to be exposed to, to have that better life. Their only fault, was thinking what we have always believed, that the United States were a compassionate people, protector of human rights, especially children.
But here is what I will say, and if it is considered judgment, so be it. If you listen to the audio of the children’s cries, stare at the photos of the children in cages, and all you can say is, “it was the parent’s fault” or “they crossed illegally and knew the risks”, and not be a voice to speak up for the children, I feel sorry for you being so heartless. And unlike Tucker Carlson who said, and I am paraphrasing, “if you don’t have kids, you don’t have to feel sorry for these children,” we are a better country than this, especially if you are going to hide behind biblical scripture.