Paul's Heart

Life As A Dad, And A Survivor

Archive for the category “Education”

Does This Help You Understand?


I wrote the other day about my inability to grieve.  I want to grieve.  I just cannot.  All too often I find myself unable to give me the levity to allow me to feel and show my emotion, because all too often, I am dealing with other issues at the same time, which do not allow me to let my guard down, be weak,  show my emotions, grieve.

I was reminded of this, when this morning my memory was jogged by two posts, one from this blog (May 18, 2014 – you can search the archive for the date), and a Facebook memory that came up today.

It was two years ago today, with my father’s health rapidly declining, that I had to appear at Family court, in spite of the possibility that my father could pass away at any moment.  Of course, the courts were not going to grant any continuance, unless it was agreed on by the other side.  It was not, and the custody hearing was held.  At its completion, I rushed back to the nursing home to be by his side.

his empty chair

This was my father’s wheelchair.  Two years ago, it had been more than two weeks that he had even been able to sit in it.

just before

The cancer at one time, had been classified as stage 1, the best chance for cure.

At this point, my father was of sound mind, when he asked me to be his health advocate.  Though I had a lot going on in my private life, my job, a school board campaign, a spouse battling an “illness”, and my own health issues, I knew that I could easily handle what my father asked me to do.

And then things went wrong, nearly everything went wrong.  My father’s cancer turned aggressive and rapidly grew to stage 4, and terminal.  Suddenly, time which was only fairly frequent with his care, became more frequent, with me often spending several nights a week with him in the hospital or nursing home.  But issues developed in my personal life that my father knew about, and in the middle of this fight, I ended up separating from my wife and filing for divorce.  Again, with all this, I was dealing with my own health issues.

My father was well aware what was happening in my house, and was still trying to offer me guidance and emotional support.  But once my father was declared terminal, I chose to no longer disclose the issues that I was facing with my divorce.  In fact, I spoke to no one about my situation, except for when the doctor, the nursing home or hospice staff needed to get in touch with me.

I dealt with bullshit rumors and innuendo, which only warranted any kind of merit, because ignorant people chose to make comments about stuff they did not know anything about, having no information.  The comments that I had to endure about my father and his final weeks, because of issues with my divorce were hurtful, and unforgivable.  These people, and I am not just talking about the obvious who were affected by the divorce, but my own family members, who had no idea the challenges that were against me, chose to attack me.

My divorce process had pressed enormous pressure on me, and decisions had to be made in my life, which were perceived as being anything but necessary.  But from a legal standpoint, I had no choice.

My father was dying.  Yet a pending court order had my back against a wall.  I had been advised by my attorney, the enormous support award that had the likelihood of being issued based on an income that I was no longer making, nor able to make.  This is called “earning capacity” and is used to prevent spouses from sandbagging their income to influence an award.  I also had someone aggressively pursuing and promising ultimate sanctions against me if I did not comply.  I was not allowed to ask for a “time out” while my father was dying.

My siblings and I got the call from hospice that my father was in the active stages of dying.  At the same time, I had plans for a job interview that was going to help me with my divorce issue, but with my father expected to soon pass, neither seemed it was going to have an impact on either.  But many days went by, and my father hung on.  Everyone was puzzled by this, as the systems of his body had clearly indicated the end was imminent.

But as the days went by, there was growing concern that I was going to have to make a decision, between honoring the orders of the family court, or being there for my father as he passed.  I had a job opportunity, out of state.  It was not a sure thing, but I had only this one opportunity.  The court would not care if I came back empty handed, the orders would stand, and my domestic situation would only get worse.

I spoke with the hospice staff about my situation, and my concerns, and my father.  Though it offered little consolation, we all came to the understanding, that my father would have wanted me to go for the job opportunity.  That job, if I were to get it, would have had major implications for my children.  My father would not have wanted me to waste that chance.

And before anyone opens their mouth about this, let me tell you something about my father.  He had over 15 years that he lost with me, because of decisions that he made in his life, following his divorce from my mother.  That man had so many regrets that he never got the chance to amend.  His granddaughters, my daughters, gave him at least some chance at his own personal redemption.  So, he understood my angst.  And I know that the decision that I made, on the morning that he passed away, was the right one.  And so I said goodbye to my father.

I got the phone call later that afternoon that he had passed away, peacefully.

I did not get the job I was hoping for, but because I was still out of state, aggressively pursuing employment, I asked that a memorial service be held for my father, on Father’s Day weekend, and I would return back home for the service, along with visiting my daughters.  It was going to be a very quick weekend, mixed with all kinds of emotions.  But never did I expect the backstabbing and innuendo that would follow.

As much as my father did not want any drama following his passing, we all blew it.  But there have been those who have chosen to take it to a different level spreading rumors and innuendo.  And that is all it is, because not one person has any of the facts because I have not discussed anything with anyone about that day, until now.

Here is the truth.  Prior to me even filing for divorce, my employer was in the process of downsizing.  Though I felt I was in fairly good standing with my union seniority, I never thought my health and my position would be an issue.  But 5 months following the filing of my divorce, it was discovered that the building that I worked in, was going to be shut down.  This meant, that movement of employees from our building to others was going to have an impact on me.  There are many who can confirm this is actually what happened.  And because of my health issues, that my employer had protected me with health restrictions since my heart surgery in 2008, there was no longer going to be enough work to keep me employed without going out on disability, which my employer was in the process of assisting me.

But the courts, and I want to be clear, I am not criticizing the court, see things only in black and white.  They did not see that this was an unintentional or preventable reduction of income, the laws allowed them to look at the salary that I once made when my issues were not as severe.  And so, in spite of submitting medical file after file confirming my disability, and of course my ex remaining silent, the court made the following ruling, that if my disability pay would not be enough, then I would have to seek additional work.  But that was impossible for two reasons.  First, how do I work (moonlight) at another job when I would be out on disability from my main employer?  Second, when I made that assertion, I was told then that I would have to just get multiple jobs.  In reality, I had not worked a regular and consistent 40 hour work week since before 2008.  And any time that I pushed my body to do so, I ended up in the emergency room, twice in serious condition (one septic), and a third time, with an undiagnosed heart episode, all within 2012.  Again, my ex knew this.  If it meant getting 4 or 5 part time jobs, this was the court’s order.  And so, I had no other choice, than to seek out employment that would accommodate my restrictions, and pay me the salary I once made that was ruled by the courts.  And time was running out for me with the court to do so.

It was not bad enough, that I had to leave my father’s side and his imminent death for one hearing, but then had to leave his bedside for an employment opportunity out of state just so that I could prevent any kind of sanctions against me.  All that I knew, was that the eventual award was going to leave me with approximately $200 per month to live on given my current disability income.  I did what I had to do, and I know my father would have understood.

But he would have been more upset not only with this criticism and judgment that I have faced from some of my own family, simply because they did not have these details, but during the weekend of his memorial, again I was criticized for my lack of “sticking around” more than just the weekend back home.  But again, here I was, trying to find employment and had interviews scheduled.  I arrived on Friday, spent the day with my daughters, and on Saturday morning/afternoon, the memorial was held.  That evening, my daughters and I took a small road trip overnight, returned on Sunday, to celebrate Father’s Day, and on the following Monday, my greatest fears were confirmed in the award that was officially handed down.  I returned to my current home that evening to continue my efforts of finding employment.  It is the opinion of some, who felt that I should have stuck around to help with the affairs.  But again, with no one knowing what I was up against, it was very easy for people to cast judgment on me.

Lost in all this, was not only not being able to mourn my father, but two little girls were also caught in this drama, and are still in the middle of it today.

I wrote the other day about myself not being able to grieve for my father, now I know why.  And the fact that I see the hurt that some have chosen to insult my father’s memory, may have something to do with it.

My dad was my best friend.  My confidante.  My dad.  And there is nothing any of you can do to take that away from me.

Censorship vs. Effect


My writing has been kind of heavy lately as I struggle with my emotions in remembering my father as of late.

So here goes an “every day” dad post.

I talk to, and see, my daughters on Facetime nearly every night.  And we talk about everything from the day at school, friends that they hang around with, Q & A, and many times, homework assistance, and often, just some plain silliness.  Every now and then, we read to each other.

My daughters have always loved reading, and being read to.  So, any time that there is an opportunity to have either read to me, I jump  on that opportunity.  Of course, my daughters are long passed Dr. Suess and the Magic Tree House series.

My oldest daughter is into “anime” these days, in particular something called “hetalia.”  I am not really sure what the whole thing is about, and to be honest, it does not matter to me.  What does matter, is that my daughter takes the time to share something with me, that makes her happy, and even happier knowing that she can share it with me.

Now of course, this level of literature, is more geared towards teenagers, so the language, imagery, and activities will be a lot stronger.  As she was reading to me, she got to a sentence that she felt the need to warn me:
“Daddy, I just need to tell you, there are occasionally some bad words.”

I held back the slight giggle I wanted to release, but this just goes to show, that my daughter did recognize that there are things that are not looked at favorably, especially for a child to say or repeat.  But since I was reading along with her on my laptop, I could see the word in question, “asses” which was being used to describe a troublemaker in the story.

That opened up an opportunity for me to explain about censorship, when it is carried too far, and just when, it is not as much necessary for censorship as much as consideration.

My oldest has always loved singing.  She went through the Kelly Clarkson phase before she was two, then Ashley Tisdale, and by age 4, she was into a catchy song by Avril Lavigne, “Girlfriend.”

girlfriend

I got a phone call from daycare one afternoon with a very concerned teacher, “Mr. Edelman, do you know what your daughter is singing?”  Innocently I said, “not really.”  I was not concerned.  “Mr. Edelman, she is singing ‘Girlfriend’ from Avril Lavigne.”  Again I held back the laughter, and then asked, “did she sing it edited or unedited?”  I knew what the concern was.  In the song, Lavigne uses what is considered two “curse” words, one definitely considered offensive.  Now my daughter had heard both versions, so my question was legitimate.  As it turned out, she did sing the edited version, so there was nothing more for me to address.

But as I had the conversation advance last night, I brought this situation up.  I mentioned that it was unfortunate that an artist like Lavigne, with connections to Disney, felt the need to include at least one very offensive word in the lyrics to that hit.  And other artists who felt the need to do so as well.  I named some artists that I knew my daughter would recognize, and she acknowledged that there were bad words in some of their songs.  And I told her, that while the songs were good, and the artists were talented, they did not need to use offensive words to get their talent out.  And who knows, they might even get more attention that way.

We also discussed how times had changed even from reading certain literature, or movies that had been edited to censor what at one time was okay to produce for effect.  Yes, both books and movies have lost their “tone” by this censorship.  We talked about how and when is the appropriate time to use the stronger words.  She had been tested a few months ago when she referred to certain presidential candidates as a certain name, not commonly heard by a teenager, but clearly adults.  Whether I agree with her sentiments or not, her teacher did not appreciate the method that was expressed to get her opinion out.  And so, we did have that talk.

That brought back a memory I had when I flipped my first middle finger, having been taught by my elders that “the middle finger doesn’t mean anything,” as if using reverse psychology would keep me from doing it.  It did not.  And as I repeatedly gave that same middle finger to my elementary school principal, proving to him that it not only meant nothing, but actually did not physically hurt anything, only got me in deeper trouble.

I am glad I have this opportunity to keep my daughters on the right track.

Vivid Memories


There are very few months that are not difficult for me to deal with emotionally.  June is when my grandmother passed away after her second fight against cancer.  November is when I was diagnosed with my cancer, Hodgkin’s Lymphoma.  December is when my stepmother was hit by a car while crossing the street.  January is when my first wife was involved in a near fatal car accident.  April is when I was faced with emergency heart surgery.  The list goes on.

The month of May brings with it a lot of emotional pain for me.

Dad1

At this time three years ago, my father, a smoker for more than 55 years, was undergoing surgery to remove  one half of his left lung due to a cancerous tumor located critically close to the heart.

My father was a private man.  He was definitely not used to getting attention, whether it be from family or friends.  When it came to dealing with this diagnosis, I found a huge similarity with how my father dealt with his diagnosis, to how I dealt with mine.  The only difference, I had no one to look up to or refer to, for helping me get through my fight with cancer.  He made it very clear even in front of the doctor who had just given him his terminal prognosis, that all he wanted was to be a survivor like me.

My father did not want this cancer discussed with anyone at this point.  In fact, he was more concerned with the care for my stepmother, whom he had cared for since her tragic accident.  To keep his situation from getting out of control and too many people involved with well-intended but ill-wanted intentions, my father confided in two people, myself and my brother.

I was glad that my father  was thinking things so clearly.  Often times, when the average person hears the diagnosis, their thought processes go out the window.  Something my father and I shared was our ability to focus on the task at hand.  We would fall apart later if needed, but for the moment, there are things that needed to be taken care of.

It was a no-brainer, that my brother was asked to handle my father’s financial and legal needs.  He was more familiar with my dad’s home environment, more importantly, those very decisions would have an impact on his mother.  My father chose to lean on me, for everything medical, something my brother had no issue with either.  We both understood our roles with our father.

My father asked me to be his medical proxy.  He knew my experience with medicine both as patient and caregiver.  My dad knew that I would ask the questions that needed to be asked, explain things to him so that he understood everything that was about to happen.  More importantly, he knew that I would protect him, advocate for his care, and if need be, respect and honor his wishes with his care, regardless of the status of his health.  He also knew that between my brother and I, that we would respect his wishes to keep things confidential until he decided when it was time to tell other family members.

Up until this point, my father had every reason to be positive.  His cancer had been classified as Stage 1, best case scenario.  The removal of the half of the lung would be expected to eradicate the tumor, and any potential cancerous cells nearby the tumor.

I do not know if I am a worse patient, or caregiver.  I get frustrated in both roles.  I knew the surgery would not be a “walk in the park.”  Surgery would last many hours.  But we were all confident that this was the best option for my father, and he would be able to recover and go on with his life.

Many hours went by, and then I was informed that the surgery was successful and my father was in the recovery room.  The nurse mentioned that he had actually been there for some unusual amount of time.  They were still waiting for him to come out of the anesthesia.  No one seemed alarmed by this.

In anticipation of something being more complicated, I made some phone calls.  I had to arrange for more involved coverage for my stepmother’s care.  I phoned my employer to let them know that I may need some extended time off.  I also had a local election campaign that was getting ready to do some publicity events, and I informed them that I would be unavailable until further notice.  I was prepared for the worse, now I would just hope for the best.

They wheeled my father in to his room, and as to be expected, he was in some pain.  And I made sure that the pain was addressed and dealt with.  He still was not very coherent, but he was able to express his discomfort.

Over the next 24 hours, I would only leave his bedside for a short time, to run home to get showered and changed into new clothes, and stop by my dad’s house to let my stepmother know that “the old goat” was doing okay and recovering.  The next part of the recovery from this phase was of course to begin drinking and eating.  But he was really having none of it.  And it was pretty much just chalked up to the trauma that his body had just been put through.  Everything else seemed to be okay upon exams by doctors and nurses on their rounds.

The second day following his surgery, some strange things were noted.  I had driven back home to shower and change again.  My brother called me to ask me where I had place our dad’s reading glasses.  I told him they were in the drawer by his bed, and then asked why?  My dad was complaining that he could not even see the coffee cup right in front of him.  I insisted to my brother that my father was not “blind” and he did not need his glasses for drinking coffee, yet my brother insisted that was what my father was saying.  In my mind, I could recall plenty of times that I had seen my father without glasses, and at no time, was he not able to see.

Upon my return to the hospital,  stopped by the cafeteria.  I knew my father had not eaten yet, and admittedly, hospital food is really not tasty, especially when it is dictated by diet.  But it was two days now, I decided to get something from the cafeteria that I knew my dad would eat, mozzarella sticks.  My father wore dentures (for those not old enough to know what they are… false teeth).  He had placed them in his mouth earlier before my arrival.  But as I showed him the tasty snack I had brought for him, I did not say what it was, figuring he would see what it was and that would be that.

He questioned where his dentures were.  I told him that he already had them in his mouth.  He seemed to get frustrated with me like  I was messing around with him.  For my dad, he does not have a practical joke style sense of humor, so as he reached into his mouth, he pulled them out, and proceeded to argue with me, that he did not have them.  Worse yet, he placed them down, and then began to tug aggressively at his bare gums.  Something was definitely wrong.

After getting him to understand that he needed to put them back in, he proceeded to grab one of the cheese sticks, took a bite, and gave a content and satisfying groan.  He was enjoying the tasty snack I brought for him.

“How did they get this so soft and chewy?”

My brother and I looked at each other, very confused and concerned.

“Dad, it’ a mozzarella stick.  It’s supposed to be soft and chewy.”

“No, it’s a carrot stick.  It’s orange.”

I wasted no time in arguing.  My brother and I were definitely convinced something was wrong.  We were there every time there was an evaluation for his recovery.  But his not being able to see made no sense.  When he was standing, and attempted to walk, he would drift to the right.  He would actually drift off while having a conversation with us.

A neurologist came in, and asked my father how he was feeling, to which my father said, “fine.”  Then the doctor pulled out a piece of paper, laid it on the table horizontally and drew the following pattern on the paper:

______       ________         ________             ________      _________             _______       _______

He drew seven or eight rows like this.  And then handed my father a pencil, and asked him to make a vertical line through each horizontal line.  My dad thought it was an unusual thing to ask him to do, and nonchalantly completed the task… sort of.  My dad put the pencil down and stated, “finished.”

The neurologist questioned, “are you sure?”  My dad said yes and the neurologist moved the paper a couple of inches to the right, revealing to my father that he had missed the entire left half of the columns of lines.  My dad commented that he honestly thought he was done, and then proceeded to actually finished the paper.

Then the neurologist looked at my brother and I.  I think your father has had a stroke.

He was immediately ordered to undergo scans which revealed my father had actually suffered two strokes, one in the front of the brain, and one in the rear.

His care getting more complicated, I had to make arrangements to juggle my job, my home, my family, my campaign.  But not only was he my father, I was his caregiver, his advocate.  Everything in my life would not be challenged to its limits over the next year and a half.  I gave my word to my father, that I would honor all of his wishes, how he wanted things communicated, quality of life issues, and of course, end of life.   I could not handle these as his son.  I had a responsibility as his caregiver and proxy.  His cancer would actually be found to have spread, and become more aggressive.

Of course in the midst of all this, I would end up filing for divorce several months later, not due to my father’s health, but my father’s care would be brought into the process as if to justify and question my whereabouts, my commitment to my family.  But with the reactions to the divorce being extremely negative, words were never going to be satisfactory enough to explain anything.  I would discuss of my dad’s health with my daughters, explaining where and what I was doing, assuring them that grandpa was in good hands.  My employer was completely understanding with my father’s failing health.

There is a lot more to my dad’s story, but for the purpose of this post, my father ended up passing away, a little over a year later.  That anniversary is coming up soon.  It is a time that I will never forget for several reasons.  But the most painful one for people to understand, as I do not discuss it, are certain actions that occurred with my father towards the end.  The divorce process would actually involve my father’s health and passing when an accusation of “not being there for my wife” was made during her recovery from an elective surgical procedure that I had asked her to delay until my father’s health was resolved one way or the other and she chose not to do so.  And I know what was being attempted and it was going to fail miserably because I could prove where I was and what was happening.  Clearly this was a piece of scum attorney for making that statement, my wife told her about the situation, and the attorney decided to use typical “out of context” approach , that I “was not there for my wife in her time of need”, but bottom line, my wife allowed the comment to be made because all is fair in divorce court to get everything you possibly can right?  I nearly leapt from my chair, my attorney restraining me that I would get my opportunity to explain.  I SHOULD NEVER HAVE HAD TO EXPLAIN!!!  THIS SHOULD NEVER HAVE BEEN BROUGHT UP!!!  MY DAD HAD NOTHING TO DO WITH THE DIVORCE!!!

Upon my turn for testimony, my attorney asked me where I was during her recovery from elective surgery.  “I was by my father’s bedside as he was fighting for his life against lung cancer.”  There was no further questioning.  And no one in that courtroom would even look me in the eye afterwards.

My father’s final time with me was hard enough.  I have never really been able to grieve for him, because as his caregiver and proxy, I could not afford to let my emotions interfere with what he had wanted.  And nearly everyone had a hard time understanding that about me, that I was actually doing it.  I was his son and should have acted differently, go against what my father had wanted.  But I did not, which is why my father was very clear about having asked me to be his proxy and caregiver.  And I know that to this day, discussion combining my father and the divorce is still happening.  Funny though, for all the things people “know,” no one has even talked to me about it.  The only conversation really was held in a divorce court.

Yes, May is very hard for me.  I have no regrets for honoring my father’s wishes.  I miss my friend, my confidante, my dad, immensely.  May was made harder than it ever should have.  But I can only deal with my thoughts.  Not worry about the innuendo and conspiracy theories that others want to generate to provide some sort of justification.

20140331_201537

Post Navigation