Paul's Heart

Life As A Dad, And A Survivor

P.T. Barnum – A Good Dad


As far as circus movies go, The Greatest Showman is making quite a buzz this year, most notably for the mix of storyline and musical numbers.  Though not 100% accurate, the movie tells of the background to the origins of the what until its closing, became known as the Ringling Brothers, Barnum, & Bailey Circus.  The Greatest Showman is not the first foray into movies about the circus.  Decades ago, a film called The Greatest Show On Earth directed by legendary Cecil B. Demille, took place  years later into the circus as it had become a travelling show.

Of course, the time periods were not the only difference between the two films, star of The Greatest Showman, Hugh Jackman looked nothing like the real Phineas Taylor Barnum.  Definitely no mistaking their lack of a resemblance.

Because I do not wish to spoil anything from either movie, I will not go into much details about either movie.  However, in The Greatest Showman, while the film chronicles the beginning of one of the greatest conmen known, also ironically described as a philanthropist, though he would only admit to doing charity work if there was a profit for him, the subplot revolved around wanting a difference for his children as opposed to the lifestyle he was raised in.

P.T. Barnum was portrayed as a street rat hustler, conning to survive.  When he meets the love of his life, clearly from the other side of the tracks, and with her support, he builds a museum of freaks which would eventually grown into the 3-ring circus.  His motive was clear, he wanted only better for his children, than what he had experienced as a child, being laughed at for his status in society, poor.

Seriously, what parent would not want a better life for their children than they had growing up?  No matter how well off or how much a person struggled, it would only be natural to want better.  The problem for Barnum, as portrayed in the movie, as his efforts and success grew, he lost sight of why he was doing what he had done.  Branching out into theater on top of his museum of novelty freaks, he hardly spent time with his family.  And in one fell swoop, it would be gone.  And not just the museum and theater.

Growing up as a child in a divorced family, I know the struggle my mother faced with my father estranged.  I know what it was like to do without, money or a father.  I know what it is like to enter the world of adulthood without a penny in your pocket, or prepared for being on your own.  All I know is, like Barnum, I wanted better for my own daughters.  Just as Barnum needed to be reminded, when my father and I had mended our relationship, he even complimented me on my efforts that regardless of how well things were going for me, that I always appeared to not forget where I came from.

As my daughters grew, there were obstacles in my way as well.  First, a critical health scare changed how I lived me life, at least until denial overcame those issues, only to be faced repeatedly five years later with more extreme health crisis, all related to treatments of Hodgkin’s Lymphoma almost 30 years ago.  But as I faced these challenges, I did all I could to overcome the deficits, especially financially.  Until I got to the point where I heard from my oldest daughter, “I wish you didn’t have to work so much.”

That should have been a wake up call for me as to how at least one of my daughters was feeling.  But I was so driven to provide everything I possibly could for my children.  Five years after my heart surgery, I almost died again, as the exhaustive way I lived my life, was destroying my body.  And along with it, would have been any future with my children.

Other issues would come up, and all of a sudden, everything that I had worked for, everything that I had hoped for my children, was gone.  I was no better off than the day I graduated from high school, in fact, perhaps even worse.

My children know how much I did for them.  They also know how much I wanted better for them.  But they also believe in me, that I will still do all that I can, even in the short time that I have left either in their childhood, or my cancer survivorship, they will be better off than I was.  Already I see so many differences in both of them compared to my childhood, from academics to social interactions.  I remain involved in both of their educations, encouraging and providing guidance when needed.  They have gotten so good however, that now they are scheduled to take Honors level schoolwork, something I have never done.  Socially, they are way more accepted in school than I was.  I feel that now is the time, and that I can concentrate more on life lessons for them in regard to relationships and what to expect from others and what to accept.  I want them to learn the value of money, learning to live within their means.  I want them to learn the lesson I clearly forgot, as did Barnum, do not forget to take time for your family.

Barnum got more time to do better in doing better for his family.  As am I.  I do as much as I can to communicate and visit with my daughters as often as I can.  I can tell that they both respect me, and love me.  I can see their independence developing in each of them, and soon, they will want to make decisions on their own.  And they will do well.  They both know how proud of them for the respect they not only give, but for the respect they deserve.  I still have more to do, but I believe that I have done better for them, and have time to do more.

Clearly Barnum did turn things around, and once on better footing, returned to what was important to him, his daughters, while others took care of the business.

I do not need to watch anymore circus movies, because one of my snacks will always remind me of what I need to keep in mind first and foremost, my children.

Awesome by themselves, or with any kind of condiment or added to a special treat.

Congratulations Stephanie!!!


I want to give an extremely happy update on someone that was featured on “Paul’s Heart” several years ago, Stephanie.  You can read her story under “Pages”, titled “Stephanie’s Words.”

Stephanie is a survivor of Hodgkin’s Lymphoma like me, but unlike me, she is young and I must admit, a determination stronger than me.  Our journeys with Hodgkin’s were quite different, and our life in remission is also quite different.  But as you can see in the photo collage, she has come a long way over the years.

Well, if you are someone dealing with cancer, whether at the beginning stages, nearing the end, or beginning your new life after cancer… then look no further to see that there is life after cancer.

Stephanie got married last week to her long time boyfriend, and when I say long time, I mean that he was with her through her battle with Hodgkin’s.  Together, they were already tested with “better or worse, sickness and health.”  Stephanie and her husband are a formidable team having gone through one of the most difficult times in their lives, and that was before they were married.

Along with continued remission, remember Stephanie, I am always “looking in my rear view mirror on the road of remission to make sure that you are still following me.”  I look for more big milestones in your remission, but even bigger things to come for you and your husband.  Congratulations Stephanie.

A Day To Be Recognized, Not Celebrated


Publisher’s note – this particular post is a general post, not reflective of any particular situation that I may or may not be dealing with personally.  Furthermore, this post is being written gender neutral, as it is a topic that affects both genders.

Just as I am an advocate for cancer survivors and patients, universal health care, and adoption, I am also an advocate against something called “Parental Alienation.”  Today is the annual recognition of Parental Alienation.

To be clear, this is an issue that affects both mothers and fathers, but also extended family members such as grandparents.  But what exactly is Parental Alienation?  First, it should not be confused with the term “Parental Alienation Syndrome” which is completely different, though it is considered the next level from Parental Alienation.  According to Psychology Today, Parental Alienation is the “psychological manipulation of the children against a targeted parent.”  This is not necessarily a custodial parent vs. non-custodial either.  The action of Parental Alienation is “psychological manipulation” which simply means causing the child to think differently about either parent, usually in a negative sense.  Simply put, talking mean about the other parent so that the child wants nothing to do with the targeted parent.  This type of emotional abuse actually can occur with extended family members as targets as well, such as grandparents, aunts and uncles, siblings.  The individual actually manipulating the child will have one or more targets.

Parental Alienation Syndrome is actually when the manipulation has been completed, and the child, who under normal circumstances would unconditionally love both parents, now tries at all costs, to avoid the targeted parent, even to a level of hatred themselves comparable to the offending parent.

What would cause one parent to go after another parent, and use the child in this manner?  Clearly it is to serve as some sort of revenge, either for a system that the antagonist perceives did not give the desired result, or even if the desired result was reached, the decision was not enough.  The hatred of the target by the other parent, is more than the love the parent has for the child.  That does not mean that the offending parent does not love their child, the offending parent just hates the targeted parent more.

No one gets married with the ultimate goal of getting divorced, well unless you get involved with a pre-nuptial agreement, then I believe you pretty much do not have confidence in your marriage lasting.  I do not have the secret formula to what makes a marriage last “til death” parts the spouses, or when the marriage simply falls apart.  And the reasons that marriages do fall apart are numerous, from issues such as money problems, to even getting married under false pretenses.  But at no point, should this EVER affect the children.

And that is exactly how Parental Alienation works, by drawing the children into the failed marriage.  Only the two spouses are the ones married and divorced, not the children.  The children will keep the same parents as they had when they were married.  However, when one parent is driven to cause as much hurt as possible, children do get used as a weapon to hurt the targeted parent.  Make no mistake, this is emotional abuse, child abuse.  No child, under normal circumstances will hate their parents, unless they are convinced to, and this is Parental Alienation.  When the targeted parent is no longer able to be involved with the child, now by the child’s choice, this is Parental Alienation Syndrome.  In the short run, what this means to the offending parent, “good, I got what  I wanted, my child hates (the other parent) and I know that parent is hurting now because of that.  I have now hurt the targeted parent as much as they have hurt me.”    Think about it, the parent seeks revenge, uses the child to do so, and succeeds.  Sure, the targeted parent has now “paid” for their transgression and nerve for filing for divorce.  But now you have a child, or children, who will have not only parental issues, trust issues, and relationship issues in their future lives.

The offending parent does not take the harm to the child into consideration.  All that matters is what occurs to the targeted parent at all costs.  But just as any traumatic event in a child’s life, whether it be abuse, loss (death) of a parent, auto accident or fire, the child who grows up resenting their targeted parent faces a couple of major issues.  There are all kinds of shocking statistics that point to risky behaviors of children of alienated parents, but one thing is certain, it is not something the child will ever forget.  And just as the offending parent will feel victorious, vindicated, eventually the child will discover the manipulation, and the role that they themselves played, or were played.  And then a whole new set of issues will develop.

So how does a child get manipulated against their other parent?  Involving the child in discussions pertaining to the divorce process from court orders to the issues of the divorce.  Lies.  Talking negatively about the targeted parent.  Wrangling support from outsiders (family and friends) to “verify” the things said about the targeted parent.  Really, anything that causes the unnatural act of turning a child against their parent.  That is manipulation.

And while “parent” is in the term, the act is actually involving the child, there are things done to add to the hurt caused to the targeted parent which is meant to reduce any fight the targeted parent may put up.  Keeping the targeted parent from communicating or seeing the child, not sharing simple things like photos and report cards, not informing the targeted parents of medical issues that arise are all acts of parental alienation, because the purpose is there, to alienate the child from the targeted parent, to erase the parent from the child’s life.

And those outsiders that actively participate or encourage the unnatural act of turning a child against their parent, may actually be considered worse because they are not as emotionally involved as the offending parent, then presumably should have a clearer head, to see the hurt being caused to the child.  Again, do you hate the targeted parent more than you love the child?  Then you are guilty of Parental Alienation.

I am an adult child of divorce.  I grew up hearing awful things about my parent by outsiders.  My parent chose to not deal with all the hatred and manipulation by the others.  And so, as much as I loved that parent, I grew to hate that parent.  And as visits diminished, the hatred grew because clearly, everyone else was right.  And the absence of my parent proved it.  But a tragedy early in my adulthood would open a door that had been slammed shut by me.  Now, I am not the kind of person to hold a grudge, even in this extreme case.  I never did ask either of my parents why they got divorced, and with my father no longer living, I do not want to know, being able to hear only one side at this point.  I have forgiven, moved on, but have not forgotten.

I love my daughters.  I did divorce from their mother, but I did not divorce their mother.  I divorced from my wife.  And that is why it has been so important to me to not allow to happen to my daughters what happened with me, because I know how it feels.  Because our daughters will outlive both of their parents, and most likely have a family of their own, their mother and I will need  to co-exist as mother and father.  There are children that are not as fortunate.  Those children will never get the chance to stop the hurt, never get the chance to forgive.  And that is what today is all about.

Post Navigation